Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s day by day e-newsletter that retains readers on top of things on essentially the most important Texas information.
Joy Alonzo, a revered opioid professional, was in a panic.
The Texas A&M University professor had simply returned dwelling from giving a routine lecture on the opioid disaster on the University of Texas Medical Branch when she realized a pupil had accused her of disparaging Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick in the course of the speak.
In the few hours it took to drive from Galveston, the criticism had made its strategy to her supervisors, and Alonzo’s job was all of a sudden in danger.
“I am in a ton of trouble. Please call me!” she wrote to Chandler Self, the UTMB professor who invited her to talk.
Alonzo was proper to be afraid. Not solely had been her supervisors concerned, however so was Chancellor John Sharp, a former state comptroller who now holds the highest-ranking place in the Texas A&M University System, which incorporates 11 public universities and 153,000 college students. And Sharp was speaking immediately with the lieutenant governor’s workplace concerning the incident, promising swift motion.
Less than two hours after the lecture ended, Patrick’s chief of workers had despatched Sharp a hyperlink to Alonzo’s skilled bio.
Shortly after, Sharp despatched a textual content on to the lieutenant governor: “Joy Alonzo has been placed on administrative leave pending investigation re firing her. shud [sic] be finished by end of week.”
The textual content message was signed “jsharp.”
For free speech advocates, well being consultants and college students, Texas A&M’s investigation of Alonzo was a surprising demonstration of how shortly college leaders permit politicians to intrude in classroom discussions on matters in which they don’t seem to be consultants — and one other instance of growing political involvement from state leaders in how Texas universities are managed.
The revelation comes as Texas A&M is reeling over considerations that the college allowed politically motivated outsiders to derail the hiring of Kathleen McElroy, a Black journalism professor on the University of Texas at Austin, to revive the journalism faculty at Texas A&M. The subsequent outcry over how Texas A&M dealt with the scenario prompted the college president to resign final week, and the interim dean of arts and sciences stepped down from that position however will stay a professor.
In an e-mail obtained by The Texas Tribune by means of a public data request, Alonzo informed Self the investigation had been kicked off by a pupil “who has ties to Texas A&M Leadership.”
The Texas A&M system confirmed the collection of telephone calls and textual content messages that led to Alonzo’s investigation was kicked off by Texas Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham, a graduate of UTMB’s medical faculty. The Tribune confirmed her daughter, a first-year medical pupil on the time, attended Alonzo’s lecture. Buckingham served six years in the Texas Senate with Patrick, who endorsed her run for land commissioner final yr, and he or she lately attended Sharp’s marriage ceremony in May.
Buckingham declined to remark.
Just a few hours after Texas A&M began wanting into the criticism, course leaders at UTMB despatched an e-mail to college students in the category saying Alonzo’s feedback “about Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick and his role in the opioid crisis” didn’t characterize the opinion of the college.
The e-mail additionally included a “formal censure” of Alonzo, though it didn’t specify what she stated that was offensive.
Neither UTMB nor Texas A&M would affirm what Alonzo stated that prompted such a response, and UTMB college students interviewed by the Tribune recalled a obscure reference to Patrick’s workplace however nothing particular.
UTMB declined to remark for this story, and Alonzo declined to be interviewed.
Ultimately Texas A&M allowed Alonzo to maintain her job after an inner investigation couldn’t affirm any wrongdoing.
In an announcement, Texas A&M University System spokesperson Laylan Copelin stated Sharp’s textual content to Patrick was a “typical update,” saying it isn’t uncommon for the chancellor to “keep elected officials informed when something at Texas A&M might interest them.”
“It is not unusual to respond to any state official who has concerns about anything occurring at the Texas A&M System,” stated Copelin, who stated the system adopted customary process to look into the declare.
Patrick didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Adam Steinbaugh, an lawyer with the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a nonprofit authorized group centered on defending free speech on faculty campuses, stated “it would be highly inappropriate for a university to conduct an investigation if a faculty member says something critical of a state leader or a government official.”
“That is, I think, a misuse of institutional resources, and it’s one that will have a chilling effect and that has a chilling effect even if you wind up clearing the professor,” Steinbaugh stated.
A day after the criticism about Alonzo’s speak, Marcia Ory, a professor at Texas A&M Health and co-chair of the college’s Opioid Task Force with Alonzo, warned concerning the long-term penalties.
“The incident in Galveston yesterday is probably an indicator of how sensitive and politically charged this topic is and the need to tread lightly and be aware that anything can be taken out of context,” Ory wrote in an e-mail to Jon Mogford, vp of Texas A&M Health.
“It’s a shame because all we want is to make people aware of harm-reduction strategies that can save lives, especially among youth and young adults who are especially vulnerable these days,” wrote Ory, who didn’t reply to a request for remark.
An professional with a stable repute
Alonzo has spent greater than 20 years as a pharmacist in Japan, Missouri and elsewhere, and has taught faculty college students in Texas for greater than a decade. She now teaches at Texas A&M whereas working as an ambulatory care pharmacy director at a free well being clinic in Bryan.
She has helped carry thousands and thousands of federal analysis {dollars} to the college, and final yr Texas A&M’s pharmacy faculty named her the early profession researcher of the yr.
One of Alonzo’s current initiatives focuses on coaching folks to make use of Narcan, a nasal spray that reverses opioid results and might save lives in overdose instances. She’s additionally suggested state leaders on different public insurance policies that would enhance the battle towards opioid overdoses.
Fentanyl, an artificial opioid usually illegally manufactured by Mexican drug cartels, is a rising drawback. Between 2019 and 2021, overdose deaths involving fentanyl in the state rose practically 400%.
This yr, Gov. Greg Abbott declared cracking down on fentanyl as one of his seven precedence points for the legislative session.
Lawmakers allotted $18 million over the subsequent two years towards offering naloxone, an opioid-reversing drug, to police, colleges and neighborhood organizations on the entrance strains of the epidemic. To enhance the federal government’s response to overdose spikes, in addition they handed legal guidelines requiring police and different public entities to report overdoses to a public well being company.
But as a substitute of backing different really useful methods to scale back overdose deaths, resembling legalizing check strips that may detect the presence of fentanyl in different medication, lawmakers centered on a extra punitive method, approving legal guidelines that enhance prison penalties for offering fentanyl that results in an overdose loss of life.
Public well being consultants like Alonzo have largely supported harm-reduction efforts reasonably than growing punishments for drug customers. As the disaster intensified, Alonzo usually acquired pressing emails from Texas faculty districts and legislation enforcement businesses anticipating coaching and naloxone kits. In the previous, she estimated she had given away greater than $4.5 million value of naloxone by means of her coaching classes.
Statement of formal censure
Self, the professor at UTMB, scheduled Alonzo to offer the lecture to the first-year medical college students months in advance.
“I can’t tell you enough how much the students value this presentation,” Self wrote in October, in line with emails obtained by means of an open data request. “I get feedback all the time from them telling me how important they view this talk. They’ll come up to me even months later to tell me.”
On March 7, the 2 began the day with breakfast on the laid-back Mosquito Cafe in Galveston earlier than heading to the lecture, which was obligatory for college students to attend.
The lecture was not recorded, however in line with presentation slides obtained by the Tribune by means of an open data request, Alonzo gave college students a broad overview of the opioid disaster and the science behind opioids. She walked them by means of methods to forestall opioid deaths, methods to acknowledge an overdose and methods to administer naloxone. She even touched on what to do if a police canine was uncovered to fentanyl.
The slides present that Alonzo mentioned how an absence of infrastructure limits the state’s skill to reply to the disaster, noting that many Texas counties lack a health worker; reporting on opioid deaths by emergency rooms is rare; and lots of legislation enforcement businesses and native well being departments don’t observe opioid deaths.
This means the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention considers Texas a nonreporter in relation to opioid knowledge, which makes it harder for researchers to obtain grants to sort out the difficulty. (Alonzo gave her presentation earlier than the Legislature handed new reporting legal guidelines this yr.)
The lecture ended round midday. Afterward, college students gathered on the entrance of the category to seize free naloxone kits supplied by Alonzo. Some caught round to ask Alonzo questions.
The course’s instructors gave no indication something had gone awry.
Alonzo acquired in her automobile and began her two-and-a-half-hour journey dwelling.
At 4:22 p.m., as Alonzo was studying {that a} controversy was brewing, a course coordinator despatched an e-mail to your entire class distancing UTMB from feedback Alonzo allegedly made about Patrick. The topic line learn, “STATEMENT OF FORMAL CENSURE.”
“The statements made by the guest lecturer do not represent the opinion or position of the University of Texas Medical Branch, nor are they considered as core curriculum content for this course,” the e-mail stated.
“UTMB does not support or condone these comments. We take these matters very seriously and wish to express our disapproval of the comment and apologize for harm it may have caused for members of our community,” the e-mail continued. “We hereby issue a formal censure of these statements and will take steps to ensure that such behavior does not happen in the future.”
The e-mail didn’t specify what feedback had led to the censure.
The bother had began a number of hours earlier when Buckingham referred to as Patrick to alert him that an A&M professor had made unfavorable feedback about him throughout a visitor lecture at UTMB, stated Copelin, the A&M system spokesperson. Buckingham then referred to as Jenny Jones, the college system’s vice chancellor for governmental relations.
Copelin stated a textual content message had alerted Buckingham of the feedback, however he didn’t present data on who despatched the textual content message.
Patrick then referred to as Sharp and Kevin Eltife, the chair of the University of Texas System’s board, Copelin stated. The name between Sharp and Patrick was brief. Patrick’s chief of workers, Darrell Davila, adopted with the textual content to Sharp that linked to Alonzo’s college web page. Eltife declined to remark.
Sharp had a workers member look into the criticism and that workers member requested then-A&M President M. Katherine Banks’ workplace to analyze.
Copelin stated Sharp’s request went by means of the chain of command at A&M’s Health Science Center and ended up with Kevin McGinnis, the system’s vp and chief compliance officer.
At the identical time, the federal government relations crew alerted the Health Science Center and the pharmacy faculty, that are affiliated with Alonzo, Copelin stated.
A&M officers acquired a replica of UTMB’s censure assertion and reached out for extra data, however UTMB didn’t cooperate, Copelin stated.
“By the close of the day, McGinnis decided to put Alonzo on paid leave and investigate to determine what really happened,” Copelin stated in an announcement.
As the scenario developed, A&M officers up to date Patrick and his crew.
At 4:43 p.m., simply quarter-hour after UTMB despatched its official censure letter, Jones alerted Patrick’s deputy chief of workers, Marian Wallace, that the investigation was underway.
“joy alonzo placed on administrative leave pending firing investigation this week js,” learn the message from Jones obtained by the Tribune by means of a public data request.
Copelin stated the college’s dealing with of the criticism towards Alonzo adopted customary process and appropriately up to date the related lawmakers on the investigation’s progress.
“The investigation into the matter was a reasonable step to take, particularly after UTMB issued a public statement ‘censuring’ one of our faculty members,” he stated. “In fact, it would have been irresponsible not to look into it.”
Texas A&M wouldn’t reply questions on what particular coverage Alonzo might have violated along with her feedback or present paperwork pertaining to the investigation, citing state legislation that permits a college to withhold such data if an individual is cleared of wrongdoing.
The timing of the criticism got here because the legislative session was heating up. Universities, together with Texas A&M, had been making pitches to lawmakers to commit some of the state’s multibillion-dollar surplus to fund particular initiatives.
Alonzo’s predicament additionally comes as Texas universities are coping with growing authorities involvement in ostensibly impartial public universities, notably on the hand of Patrick, whom Alonzo was accused of criticizing. This yr, Texas lawmakers banned variety, fairness and inclusion workplaces on faculty campuses, a precedence for Patrick. These workplaces goal underrepresented teams on campus to assist them succeed, however critics accused them of pushing “woke,” left-leaning ideology on college students and college.
Patrick additionally prioritized a invoice that may restrict sure conversations about race and gender in faculty lecture rooms. When professors at UT-Austin publicly reaffirmed their tutorial freedom to show essential race concept final yr, Patrick pledged to ban tenure in public universities. Ultimately, that proposal was unsuccessful, however college say the broad assault on increased schooling has made Texas a much less interesting and harder place to work.
Students scramble to know what occurred
When college students at UTMB acquired the e-mail hours after the lecture, a number of began texting one another, attempting to determine what Alonzo had stated that was so offensive.
According to at least one pupil who requested to stay nameless for worry of retaliation from the varsity, some college students puzzled if it was when Alonzo stated that the lieutenant governor’s workplace was one of the explanations it’s onerous for drug customers to entry sure look after opioid habit or overdoses.
A second pupil who additionally requested to stay nameless for a similar cause stated Alonzo made a remark that the lieutenant governor’s workplace had opposed insurance policies that would have prevented opioid-related deaths, and by doing so had allowed folks to die.
A 3rd pupil who additionally spoke on the situation of anonymity stated Alonzo talked about how insurance policies, just like the state’s ban on fentanyl check strips, have a direct impression on the flexibility to stop opioid overdoses and deaths. A push to legalize the check strips died earlier this yr in the Patrick-led Senate regardless of assist from prime Republicans, together with Abbott.
All of the scholars interviewed stated they felt Alonzo’s feedback had been correct they usually weren’t offended by something in the presentation.
In an announcement supplied by Copelin, the A&M system spokesperson, Alonzo stated “her remarks were mischaracterized and taken out of context,” however she didn’t affirm precisely what the feedback had been.
“She added that she had no issue with how the university handled the situation,” Copelin stated.
The third pupil at UTMB stated the e-mail from the varsity was irritating as a result of it was unclear which feedback the college discovered problematic.
“We’ve been left wondering exactly what it was they objected to,” the coed stated. “That vagueness just leads to some more self-censorship, since it’s hard to tell what is and isn’t allowed.”
Steinbaugh, an lawyer with the authorized nonprofit FIRE, stated colleges have the best to criticize an worker or visitor speaker for statements they make, however issuing a proper censure sends a robust and unambiguous message.
“That is a suggestion that if you repeat this language or these criticisms, then you will be subject to disciplinary consequences that go beyond formal censure,” he stated. “That is a way to really put an exclamation point on the chilling effect.”
In an announcement final week to college who had been upset concerning the fallout over the botched hiring of McElroy to the journalism division, Sharp expressed concern about exterior influences in the hiring and promotion of college, saying it was “never welcome, nor invited.”
Sharp stated he solely participates in hiring questions over the varsity’s president and vice chancellors for agriculture and engineering.
“Other than that, I don’t believe it is my place to be part of the hiring process for faculty,” he wrote.
Fear of a chilling impact on life-saving data
Just a few hours after Alonzo reached out to Self concerning the bother she was in, she lastly heard again. But the tone of the e-mail was notably completely different from the sooner cordial exchanges.
Self stated she didn’t document the lecture and famous that “all further correspondence will be funneled through our Office of Education.”
Self referred a request for remark by the Tribune to UTMB’s media relations division, which declined to debate the scenario.
Meanwhile, emails obtained by means of an open data request present that opioid consultants and advocates throughout the state began sending Alonzo letters of assist that night.
“I’ve never seen her to be anything other than professional, knowledgeable, and compassionate,” wrote Kathy Posey, who helped begin the Montgomery County Overdose Prevention Endeavor, an opioid overdose consciousness group made up of folks whose relations have been hooked on opioids or died from an overdose.
Lucas Hill, a medical affiliate professor of pharmacy on the University of Texas at Austin, wrote in his letter that Alonzo was not a divisive educator.
“While I was not present during her guest lecture at the University of Texas Medical Branch this morning, my interactions with Dr. Alonzo gives me great confidence that she engages learners in discussions of controversial topics with the professionalism and restraint described in established principles of academic freedom,” he wrote.
The stakes are excessive for professors who concurrently work in their fields and educate, many of whom, like Alonzo, do not need tenure. And it raises considerations that medical consultants engaged on high-stakes points just like the opioid disaster may withhold vital, life-saving data out of worry of reprimand or punishment.
“When we’re dealing with basic life-saving interventions, chilling effects can have much more deep consequences,” stated Aaron Ferguson, an habit remedy professional in Austin who works with researchers at public universities to fight opioid overdoses. “People don’t feel emboldened to share basic science that could save people’s lives.”
“Some members of the audience” had been offended
On March 21, two weeks after she was positioned on paid depart, Alonzo acquired an e-mail saying her depart had been lifted.
The following day, pharmacy faculty Dean George Udeani stated in a memo to Alonzo that in the course of the lecture she “related an anecdote and an interaction with a state official.”
“I understand that your comment did not assign blame. However, some members of the audience felt that your anecdote was offensive,” he wrote.
“While it is important to preserve and defend academic freedom and as such be able to discuss and present to students and the public the results of research observations and strategies, you should be mindful of how you present your views,” Udeani stated.
Disclosure: Texas A&M University, Texas A&M University System, University of Texas at Austin, University of Texas System and Kathleen McElroy have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded in half by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Financial supporters play no position in the Tribune’s journalism. Find an entire record of them right here.
Join us for conversations that matter with newly introduced audio system on the 2023 Texas Tribune Festival, in downtown Austin from Sept. 21-23.
…. to be continued
Read the Original Article
Copyright for syndicated content material belongs to the linked Source : Hacker News – https://www.texastribune.org/2023/07/25/texas-a-m-professor-opioids-dan-patrick/