To deal with the growing food inflation, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has proposed a National Commodity Board. A commodity board is not a novel thought, however it is a poor alternative of weapon in opposition to the hovering costs of food in Nigeria.
In Nigeria, food inflation is a downside that won’t go away. With 90% of the working inhabitants spending 60% of their revenue on food and associated bills, it’s been clear for a whereas that pressing motion is wanted. Recent numbers from the National Bureau of Statistics present that food costs are the most important driver of Nigeria’s inflation figures. It has compelled the nation’s president President Bola Tinubu to declare an emergency within the nation’s food sector. President Tinubu’s plan to cut back food costs has a number of prongs, one in every of which is the institution of commodity boards.
Commodity boards are usually not new in Nigeria. The nation has arrange boards for money crops like palm produce, cotton, groundnut and even grains. Most of those boards have been created to increase and regulate exports. Yet, they’ve usually induced market distortions and incentivised corruption till they have been finally dissolved. Tinubu’s commodity board is supposed to rein in inflation, however there is nothing to recommend that it might be any totally different from those earlier than it.
The National Commodity Board could trigger market distortion
“In the past, the commodity board improved the rural economy and brought more revenue to the farmers, but it created a toxic imbalance in the market. Another board of that sort will do the same,” Tade*, a coverage professional, stated to TechCabal. Tinubu’s proposed commodity board goals to management the price of food gadgets and repair them at a value that can revenue the farmer and nonetheless be inexpensive for the Nigerian client who is at the moment battling inflation. To guarantee this, the board establishes a value ground, which is a minimal value at which the crop might be purchased from farmers. In the previous, the boards additionally immediately purchase the produce on the pre-determined value from the farmers on a common foundation.
The downside is that many instances this fastened value is divorced from the market actuality, and in such circumstances, individuals will inevitably minimize corners and create market distortion. A transparent instance is how the federal government inadvertently created a black marketplace for {dollars} when it artificially pegged the charges beneath the actual market actuality. The similar factor occurred within the Nineteen Sixties when groundnut producers resorted to promoting their produce immediately to overseas consumers keen to pay greater costs, bypassing the Northern Nigeria Marketing Board’s established value ground. “Market distortions can occur when the board’s fixed prices fail to adequately reflect supply and demand forces,” Tade identified. This creates disparities throughout the market and fully undermines the board’s meant value stability.
The National Commodity Board might be one other fiscal burden
The implementation of a commodity board may also place a vital fiscal burden on the nation. Considering the macroeconomic surroundings of the nation, the fastened value of produce could also be unaffordable to the vast majority of the inhabitants. Under these circumstances, the board would naturally create a subsidy for the produce, and promote them to the general public at artificially decrease costs than what it initially purchased from the farmers. But Nigeria is not in a fiscal place to present subsidies. Tade expressed considerations about and believes that any type of food subsidy will nullify the fiscal positive aspects of the latest gas subsidy elimination.
Read extra:
Additionally, the board itself requires funding for important infrastructure wanted to retailer the produce and distribute it. It additionally wants to fund the a number of organisations that might be contributing to the board’s features. These organizations could embody the National Commodity Exchange (NCX), Seed Companies, National Seed Council, Research Institutes, NIRSAL Microfinance Bank, and Food Processing/Agricultural Processing associations. Each entity on the board could require monetary assets for its operations, analysis actions, market infrastructure, and different important features.
The allocation of funds to help the board’s actions can pressure the federal government’s price range, particularly contemplating different urgent socio-economic priorities.
Corruption and inefficiencies
Making this board a intermediary between producers and customers creates room for extra corruption. There is nothing that reveals that the brand new proposed board might be corruption-proof, and the very last thing Nigeria wants is one other leaking purse. In addition, different inefficiencies related to authorities businesses equivalent to delayed funds, and nepotism, can adversely have an effect on the lives of farmers, and discourage non-public sector participation and innovation.
Duplication of present constructions
The Commodities Exchange is listed as one of many organisations that is going to be a a part of the proposed board however they’ve very comparable features. Mr Akin Akeredolu-Ale, managing director and chief govt officer of the Lagos Commodities and Futures Exchange stated, “Reintroducing Commodity Boards back into the ecosystem will see duplication of functions. The existing structure required by the Commodity boards is already being implemented by the Commodities Exchanges.”
Following the ban by the Federal Government on the direct buy of farm produce by foreigners from farmers, producers have commodity exchanges to promote their items at aggressive costs. Would it not be higher for the federal government to strengthen the infrastructure, develop market linkages, and enhance the providers supplied by commodity exchanges?
Tade thinks there are a plethora of different means the federal government can decrease the costs of food. “For example, reducing the import duties on produce like wheat can significantly reduce the cost of food items like pasta and bread,” he stated.
…. to be continued
Read the Original Article
Copyright for syndicated content material belongs to the linked Source : TechCabal – https://techcabal.com/2023/07/18/nigerias-answer-to-food-inflation-is-a-commodity-board-heres-why-it-wont-work/