The Future of TikTok in the U.S.: Supreme Court Deliberations Ahead of January 19
On January 19, a significant decision regarding TikTok’s fate in the United States is anticipated as the Supreme Court appears poised to affirm legislation that could potentially lead to its ban.
/article-new/2020/08/tiktok-logo.jpg){kind=logo}
Supreme Court’s Skepticism Towards TikTok’s Defense
Bloomberg reported on recent proceedings where justices expressed significant doubts about TikTok’s defenses during oral arguments. The predominant sentiment among them was that national security concerns take precedence over free speech rights. Issues surrounding user data collection by TikTok and potential content manipulation have raised flags given China’s connections through parent company ByteDance.
Concerns from Justices About Foreign Influence
Justice Elena Kagan voiced her skepticism regarding TikTok’s claims of constitutional violations. She remarked on the specificity of the law against this foreign entity: ”The legislation directly targets this foreign corporation, which does not possess First Amendment protections.”
Similarly, Justice John Roberts pointed out Congress’s ambivalence towards expression but highlighted worries about a “foreign adversary” acquiring extensive personal information from roughly 170 million American users. He further queried potential China’s involvement with ByteDance: “Should we disregard that its ultimate parent may be obligated to conduct intelligence activities for the Chinese government?” addressing counsel for TikTok directly.
The Impending Deadline and Potential Outcomes
A ruling from the Supreme Court could arrive before January 19 or possibly extend deliberations before implementing any bans or restrictions. While TikTok has sought a temporary reprieve while awaiting appeals outcomes, it seems likely it will face a judicial examination prior to the deadline.
If upheld by the court, American app stores will be prohibited from releasing new versions of TickTock starting on January 19. Current users will retain access; however, functionality may diminish due to unauthorised updates being unavailable over time.
//
A Possible Path Forward for ByteDance
ByteDance has options available; one could involve selling off its interests in TikTok to an acceptable buyer—a move that might allow continued operation within U.S. borders post-sale should it take place after January 19th. Nonetheless, ByteDance insists such divestment isn’t feasible and claims governmental oversight in China would hinder any efforts aimed at relinquishing control over both TIkToK and its algorithm.
