The Twitter accounts that impersonate Chinese celebrities for clout and cash

China Report is MIT Technology Review’s publication about know-how developments in China. Sign up to obtain it in your inbox each Tuesday.

A rising variety of Twitter accounts have been impersonating outspoken Chinese intellectuals or celebrities. Their posts, which ceaselessly criticize the Chinese authorities, usually draw a whole bunch of 1000’s of followers earlier than the deception is publicly uncovered.

Though Twitter has been banned in China since 2009, extra Chinese customers have been accessing the platform with VPN instruments in recent times. While that typically makes the platform an vital data hub, like through the covid protests that I wrote about final 12 months, it’s additionally change into a spot rife with spam, scams, and content material farms. It solely obtained worse because the platform tuned down its moderation efforts below Elon Musk’s reign. 

But the emergence of accounts that impersonate Chinese celebrities who don’t have a Twitter presence—prone to farm followers—is a brand new pattern this 12 months.

Edgar Lu, a Chinese-American YouTuber who’s been lively on Twitter since 2019, first seen it occurring late final 12 months. He noticed a brand new account that presupposed to be from Luo Xiang, a Chinese regulation professor who gained a nationwide following for his lectures on prison regulation. Luo, who’s adored by his viewers for the information and ethical ideas that he teaches, is usually seen as a logo of justice on social media.

The account on Twitter shared Luo’s title, used his picture as an avatar, and usually commented on related subjects to these Luo would focus on in his lectures. But for Lu, a giant fan of the professor, the account’s anti-government content material smelled fishy. “As such an influential figure in China, read by tens of millions of followers, how could Luo Xiang post such explicit [anti-government] speeches on Twitter?” he asks. “Many people were worried for him. Why could Luo Xiang write this without any trouble from the police?” 

His suspicion was confirmed in December, when an acquaintance of the professor made a public assertion that Luo doesn’t have a Twitter account. 

This heavy political speak is a function of many related impersonator accounts. One purpose, Lu suggests, could possibly be that content material crucial of the Chinese authorities has attracted extra visitors and followers than different sorts, so the impersonators are going all in on such materials to maximise their attain.

Since then, the faux Luo account has modified its avatar to a statue of the Roman goddess of justice, but the title stays the identical. The account has racked up 96,000 followers, and many nonetheless assume it’s operated by the professor himself. 

Similarly, one other account pulled over 100,000 followers by pretending to be Chen Danqing, a Chinese-American artist and author. That account was publicly uncovered in May after it tweeted out a made-up dialog with an account allegedly from China’s safety division. On June 1, it instantly deleted all its tweets, modified its title and deal with, and become a soft-core porn account promoting entry to OnlyFans-like subscriber teams. 

It’s laborious to know the final word motive of those accounts, however the in a single day transition exhibits that at the least one aim of such content material farming is to cash out. Posting paid ads or promoting the account outright can quantity to a profitable enterprise.

If a faux account fails to draw a following, it could merely select a brand new id and begin one other impersonating journey. That’s what occurred with one registered in March that alleged to be Fang Bin, a Chinese nationwide who was detained for three years for sharing details about covid’s influence within the early months. By May, the account had solely round 8,000 followers, so it deserted this id, cycled by means of just a few different makes an attempt (together with “Anti-CCP Online User Alliance” and “Singaporean Delicious Food”), and settled on Cui Chenghao, a mysterious ethnic Korean blogger in China who has practically 5 million followers on Weibo. 

The complete course of has been documented by different customers holding observe of the impersonator’s distinctive Twitter ID, which stays the identical no matter modifications to its title and deal with. The final id has been extra profitable than the earlier ones, securing this account 20,000 extra followers.

After the account of Luo Xiang was confirmed as faux, Lu tried to name for individuals to unfollow and report it, however reporting for impersonation often requires the sufferer to have an actual presence on Twitter. In most of those circumstances, the victims have little incentive to register a Twitter account simply to clear their title, and reporting nearly by no means works. Twitter responded to a request for remark with its now-standard poop emoji.

Twitter has by no means been efficient at moderating content material that’s not in English, however the scenario seems to have worsened for the reason that moderation groups had been laid off after Musk took over. Last 12 months, Chinese spam bots unfold so extensively that individuals suspected they’d the Chinese authorities’s help, however it was extra probably simply spammers making an attempt to earn money.

While they don’t pose a lot direct menace to the viewers or to the individual they fake to be, these content material farms are muddying the ecosystem of Chinese-language social media platforms, Lu says. By adopting clickbait—which in China usually means political content material—to achieve followers, they’re polarizing the discourse in Chinese.  

What different faux Chinese celebrities have you ever noticed or suspected on Twitter? Let me know at zeyi@technologyreview.com.

Catch up with China

1. The Wall Street Journal had a juicy story final week about China’s plan to pay Cuba billions of {dollars} to arrange an eavesdropping facility on the island. (Wall Street Journal $)

• China outright denied it. (Reuters $)
• The White House, after initially rejecting the information, now says China has had a spy station in Cuba since 2019. (Politico)

2. A Chinese man residing in Japan is behind a community of criminals in East Asia groping girls in public, filming it, and promoting the video on-line for earnings. (BBC)

3. The Dutch authorities and universities will display Chinese college students for safety dangers if they’ve acquired scholarships funded by the Chinese authorities. (Financial Times $)

4. The Hong Kong court docket now must determine whether or not its authorities can ban a protest anthem from being distributed on-line. (New York Times $)

5. The chief of Chechnya posted a video on social media, touting Chinese-built armored autos. Now persons are questioning whether or not China has armed Russia for the conflict. (Wall Street Journal $)

6. China simply requested the final Indian journalist within the nation to depart—after India ejected each Chinese journalist earlier. (Bloomberg $)

Lost in translation

Four years after pro-democracy protests broke out in Hong Kong, 1000’s of protesters are nonetheless in authorized limbo. As the Singapore-based Chinese outlet The Initium reported, of the ten,279 individuals arrested within the protests in Hong Kong, over 6,500 have been launched on bail however haven’t had their circumstances closed. This means they’ve been residing in fixed concern that the police can summon them anytime and file official expenses. They have been allowed to journey internationally, however many nonetheless concern they may get into hassle on the borders due to their standing. 

As worldwide consideration to the Hong Kong protests waned, help teams that fashioned round jailed protesters have slowly disbanded, and many individuals of their good friend circles are contemplating emigration. But for the protesters themselves, there’s no finish in sight. In May, the brand new Hong Kong chief govt refused to provide a timeline for concluding the investigations, calling it “unrealistic.”

One thing more

On June 15—the seventieth birthday of Chinese president Xi Jinping, who’s a widely known soccer fan—Beijing shall be internet hosting a pleasant match between the nationwide soccer groups of Argentina and Australia. But even Lionel Messi, the Argentinian star, wanted to study his classes about Chinese border management. A citizen of each Argentina and Spain, he reportedly took the incorrect passport—which didn’t match his visa—and ended up being held on the airport for just a few hours, in response to Chinese state media.