Best phone carriers: Verizon vs T-Mobile vs AT&T – is it worth making a switch?

Want to check out your options for phone carriers? While prices have increased for some of the major providers this year, market competition is strong which means compelling offers for those who switch. Read along for a look at the best phone carriers in the US. We’ll cover Verizon vs T-Mobile vs AT&T as well as some of the best affordable iPhone plans from smaller carriers. This guide will also detail how to find real-world coverage maps, how to test a carrier for free instantly with eSIM, and more.

Update December 2022: Free trials via eSIM recently launched for Verizon and AT&T (via Cricket Wireless) which join T-Mobile who was the first carrier to offer the option.

We’ve also got a dedicated comparison for business plans:

• Best iPhone carriers for business: Verizon vs T-Mobile vs AT&T on performance, price, incentives

Read on for all the details on consumer plans…

Best phone carriers: Verizon vs T-Mobile vs AT&T plus budget plans

Free instant eSIM trials

While it’s been a hassle to actually try out a new carrier in the past, eSIM support on iPhone and other smartphones has opened a new opportunity for carriers.

T-Mobile, Verizon, and AT&T are taking advantage of the tech which offers potential customers the ability to instantly test out their networks for free right alongside their existing carrier.

• Start a T-Mobile eSIM trial
• Start a Verizon eSIM trial
• Start an AT&T network eSIM trial through Cricket Wireless

One of the best things with eSIM trials is you can see the signal for both your current carrier and the one you’re testing simultaneously. And you can even decide to keep using your existing carrier and number for phone calls while using the trial for cellular data.

Coverage

While Verizon has led the best phone carriers as far as having the most customers (and still is) along with the broadest coverage over the last decade, T-Mobile has gained a lot of ground with its Sprint acquisition and quick 5G deployment. That has meant Verizon and AT&T are both playing a bit of catch-up with T-Mobile on 5G coverage as they work on rolling out more mid-band spectrum.

However, Verizon did roll out its 5G UWB coverage to 175 million people at the end of 2022.

TL;DR

All of the major carriers’ coverage maps will probably look great on their websites, here are a few tips to actually figure out how coverage will really be:

• Check coverage with the independent, third-party Opensignal app
  • Opensignal gets real-world data from millions of devices and billions of measurements
• Do a quick comparison of 4G/5G coverage with Signalchecker for your area
• Do a free eSIM trial to test out the coverage
• Talk with friends, family, or people at work who use the carrier you’re considering

Remember, smaller carriers (MVNOs) lease access to networks from the major three US carriers. While you usually get the same performance, there may be data caps and throttling during times of congestion.

Speed

Like coverage, a carrier’s speed will depend on a variety of factors including your location, device, signal strength, network congestion, and more.

And if you live in a major city vs a small town, speeds can be very different. Verizon leads with the fastest 1,000+ Mbps speeds if you have 5G UWB coverage, but T-Mobile has greater availability at the moment with its more moderately fast mid-band 5G.

Here’s a look at how the three major carriers compare for average US speeds in studies from Ookla and Opensignal:

TL;DR

• Verizon has the fastest top speeds if and where you have 5G UWB coverage
• T-Mobile has the fastest average 5G speeds with more mid-band coverage

Opensignal’s results show average 5G download speeds in the US as of Q2 2022.

Best phone carriers: Price

T-Mobile touts it offers around 20% lower prices for its unlimited plans compared to AT&T and Verizon. T-Mobile also includes taxes and fees in its advertised prices.

Keep in mind these prices can change based on how many lines you need.

In contrast, T-Mobile Connect, Mint Mobile, and Consumer Cellular offer pricing as low as $10-20 per line.

Incentives and deals

All of the major phone carriers offer (at the time of writing) between $800 and $1,000 for a trade-in when buying a new device. But T-Mobile is the most aggressive with up to $650 for early termination fees or covering a current device balance.

The major carriers also include a streaming video service for free with some unlimited plans. And Verizon offers more than just the Disney+ bundle. Depending on the unlimited plan you can get additional perks like Apple Music, Apple Arcade, and more.

Meanwhile, the Uncarrier does “T-Mobile Tuesdays” to give out regular perks and savings to customers.

Both Verizon and T-Mobile give up to 50% off 5G home internet for their cellular customers.

• 5G home internet comparison: How T-Mobile and Verizon stack up with price, speed, incentives

Best affordable alternatives to major carriers

If cutting the cost of your phone bill is a top priority, check out our full guide on the best affordable iPhone plans.

We go over which of the major networks each provider uses, key features, and more with plans starting from just $10 a line.

• Best affordable iPhone plans for 2022

Best phone carriers wrap-up

It’s difficult to pick a single winner when it comes to the best phone carriers. What’s most important to you will decide that, likely between coverage in your location, price, incentives to switch, and how many lines you have.

But hopefully, now you’ve got clarity on how the major carriers compare, how to independently check network coverage, and start a hassle-free trial. Thanks for reading our guide on the best phone carriers!

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news: